Table 4
Changes in sensory evaluation of Nabak kimchi with freeze-dried ingredients during storage
Storage periods (day) | Samples1) | Odor | Taste | Texture | Overall acceptability |
Ripe odor | Off-odor | Ripe taste | Off-taste | Firmness | Toughness |
3 | A | 4.60±1.962)ns3) | 3.00±1.70ns | 3.00±1.41ns | 3.80±1.99ns | 6.90±0.74b | 3.10±1.60a | 5.20±1.14b |
B | 4.30±1.34 | 3.50±1.35 | 3.50±2.17 | 3.20±1.40 | 6.40±1.35b | 3.20±1.32a | 5.40±1.84b |
C | 4.20±1.55 | 3.80±2.04 | 3.80±1.75 | 4.30±2.21 | 2.20±1.03a | 6.20±2.15b | 3.10±1.91a |
D | 3.90±0.88 | 3.90±1.97 | 3.80±1.93 | 4.40±2.12 | 2.40±1.26a | 6.20±2.10b | 3.10±1.85a |
E | 3.60±1.17 | 4.20±2.39 | 3.70±1.95 | 4.70±2.31 | 2.10±1.29a | 6.30±2.50b | 2.60±1.43a |
6 | A | 4.40±1.07ns | 3.20±1.40ns | 3.80±1.14ns | 2.30±0.95a | 6.50±0.97b | 3.30±2.11a | 5.90±1.20b |
B | 4.20±1.14 | 3.60±1.96 | 3.70±1.06 | 2.60±1.07a | 6.40±0.84b | 3.30±1.89a | 5.20±1.03b |
C | 3.70±1.34 | 4.30±1.89 | 4.00±1.05 | 3.70±1.70ab | 1.80±1.32a | 6.20±2.10b | 2.60±0.97a |
D | 4.00±1.56 | 4.10±2.08 | 3.70±1.42 | 3.50±1.84ab | 2.20±1.40a | 5.70±1.83b | 2.80±1.03a |
E | 3.50±1.08 | 4.10±1.66 | 4.00±0.94 | 4.50±2.17b | 1.80±1.40a | 6.30±2.50b | 2.30±0.95a |
10 | A | 5.10±1.37ns | 2.70±1.34ns | 4.60±1.51ns | 3.20±1.14ns | 6.00±0.82b | 3.40±1.07a | 5.30±0.95b |
B | 4.50±1.90 | 3.10±0.99 | 4.30±1.34 | 3.20±1.14 | 6.70±0.67b | 3.10±0.99a | 5.10±1.10b |
C | 4.70±1.89 | 3.90±1.66 | 4.30±1.49 | 4.40±1.84 | 2.40±1.35a | 6.20±1.99b | 2.30±1.25a |
D | 4.20±1.75 | 3.40±1.65 | 4.20±1.48 | 4.30±1.83 | 2.20±1.14a | 6.60±1.84b | 2.22±0.83a |
E | 4.40±1.78 | 4.10±1.37 | 4.20±1.81 | 4.80±2.10 | 2.00±1.25a | 6.50±2.32b | 2.00±1.05a |
14 | A | 6.60±0.70b | 2.20±0.92a | 6.10±0.74ab | 2.40±0.97a | 6.50±1.27b | 3.40±1.51a | 6.90±1.10b |
B | 5.80±1.14b | 2.70±1.34ab | 6.20±1.23b | 2.40±1.17a | 6.30±1.34b | 3.20±1.03a | 6.40±1.17b |
C | 4.50±1.27a | 3.30±2.16ab | 5.10±1.52ab | 3.30±1.89ab | 2.00±0.94a | 6.30±1.95b | 3.00±1.05a |
D | 4.50±1.72a | 3.40±1.78ab | 5.20±1.14ab | 4.10±2.02ab | 1.60±0.70a | 6.70±2.00b | 2.80±1.32a |
E | 4.40±1.65a | 4.00±2.36b | 4.80±1.93a | 4.90±2.47b | 1.30±0.48a | 7.80±1.40b | 2.10±1.29a |
21 | A | 6.00±2.36ns | 1.90±0.74a | 6.20±1.93ns | 3.20±1.62a | 6.10±1.52b | 3.50±1.84a | 6.50±1.90c |
B | 6.40±1.90 | 3.20±1.87ab | 6.70±1.16 | 4.20±2.35ab | 6.10±1.45b | 4.10±1.79a | 6.40±1.26c |
C | 5.60±1.71 | 4.70±2.50b | 5.90±1.37 | 4.50±2.42ab | 2.50±1.27a | 6.50±2.07b | 3.20±1.69b |
D | 5.80±2.25 | 5.20±2.35b | 5.60±1.65 | 6.10±2.33b | 1.70±1.06a | 6.70±1.89b | 1.70±1.25a |
E | 5.30±2.00 | 5.20±2.74b | 6.00±1.49 | 5.00±2.21ab | 2.10±1.29a | 6.90±1.45b | 2.30±1.25ab |
28 | A | 6.30±1.06c | 2.30±1.42a | 6.30±1.42ns | 3.60±1.84a | 7.20±0.92b | 3.30±1.83a | 6.20±1.69b |
B | 6.00±1.25bc | 2.90±2.02ab | 6.60±1.35 | 3.80±1.87ab | 6.60±1.26b | 3.20±1.69a | 5.60±2.01b |
C | 5.20±1.62abc | 4.60±2.22bc | 5.5.±2.27 | 5.40±2.17bc | 2.40±1.58a | 6.10±2.33b | 3.00±2.31a |
D | 4.60±1.71ab | 4.80±2.04c | 4.50±2.22 | 6.00±1.76c | 2.00±0.94a | 5.90±2.18b | 2.40±1.51a |
E | 4.30±2.00a | 5.60±2.12c | 5.00±2.91 | 6.40±1.58c | 1.80±0.92a | 5.90±2.69b | 2.10±1.20a |
A, Control; B, Raw ingredients and freeze-dried minor ingredients; C, Freeze-dried ingredients and minor ingredients; D, Freeze-dried radish and minor ingredients; E, Freeze-driedcabbage and minor ingredients.
Mean±SD.
Any means in the same row (a-g) or column (A-E) followed by different letters are significantly (p<0.05) different by Duncan's multiple range test.