Table 4. Organic acids of solid-fermented mesh depending on grain materials
Organic acids (mg/L) | The number of fermentation times | Sorghum | Corn | Wheat | Barley | Millet |
Malic acid | 1st | ND1) | ND | ND | 10.1±1.03a | ND |
2nd | ND | ND | 1.22±0.32a | ND | ND |
3rd | ND | 0.55±0.95a | 2.84±1.28a | 1.2±0.03 | ND |
Ascorbic acid | 1st | ND | ND | ND | ND | ND |
2nd | ND | ND | 8.59±0.25a | ND | ND |
3rd | ND | ND | 5.7±0.39a | 6.05±0.57a | 9.73±16.86a |
Lactic acid | 1st | 75.26±9.26a2) | 63.13±19.8a | 27.28±3.59b | 28.32±1.37b | 27.41±5.11b |
2nd | 116.84±56.11a | 95.87±34.35ab | 51.78±23.59b | 43.59±14.03b | 92.33±14.17ab |
3rd | 82.05±45.89a | 89.98±12.17a | 63.31±17.84a | 98.26±3.21a | 71.28±9.69a |
Acetic acid | 1st | 45.52±9.08a | 28.69±6.73b | 15.33±2.85b | 20.22±1.11bc | 25.7±2.89c |
2nd | 143.1±157.45a | 52.94±5.31a | 28.51±16.83a | 40.21±15.25a | 83.43±63.09a |
3rd | 103.63±64.1a | 62.33±9.25a | 69.77±18.79a | 67.47±25.46a | 52.21±12.3a |
Citric acid | 1st | ND | ND | 4.89±2.8b | 16.08±2.3a | 18.9±0.84a |
2nd | ND | ND | 1.16±0.66a | 1.73±2.99a | ND |
3rd | ND | ND | 1.22±0.29a | 0.33±0.39b | ND |
Succinic acid | 1st | 40±2.06a | 31.26±7.65b | 11.5±0.43d | 16.45±2.22cd | 18.92±1.53c |
2nd | 40.87±6.55a | 27.06±12.31b | 17.53±1.35b | 12.84±3.8b | 22.45±7.74b |
3rd | 24.66±8.18a | 16.13±3.88ab | 19.92±1.48ab | 14.38±0.28b | 22.65±6.04ab |
Fumaric acid | 1st | ND | ND | ND | ND | ND |
2nd | ND | ND | 0.58±1a | ND | ND |
3rd | ND | ND | 1.17±1.01a | 0.67±1.17a | ND |
Propionic acid | 1st | ND | ND | ND | ND | ND |
2nd | ND | ND | 3.37±0.46ab | 6.84±6.33a | ND |
3rd | ND | 1.23±2.13b | 4.72±3.19ab | 4.74±0.88ab | 13.55±12.39a |
Not detected.
Mean±SD (n=3) within each column followed by different letters is significantly different (p<0.05).