Enzyme products | Initial conditions | After fermentation | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Added conc. (mg/L) | Amylase activity | Alcohol (%) | pH | Acidity (acetic acid, %) | Amino acidity (glycine, %) | Reducing sugar (%) | Total sugar (%) | |||
Gluco- (A) | Alpha- (B) | Modified- (A+0.56B) | ||||||||
Chung-moo purified enzyme | 200 | 2.70 | 27.89 | 18.32 | 9.17±0.06f | 3.87±0.02e | 0.10±0.00a | 0.02±0.00b | 0.10±0.01b | 2.03±0.20a |
400 | 5.41 | 55.78 | 36.64 | 15.79±0.05d | 4.24±0.01f | 0.05±0.00d | 0.02±0.00b | 0.08±0.01bc | 1.51±0.10b | |
500 | 6.76 | 69.73 | 45.81 | 15.29±0.03e | 3.73±0.01d | 0.09±0.00b | 0.03±0.00a | 0.09±0.02b | 0.41±0.04c | |
600 | 8.11 | 83.67 | 54.97 | 17.81±0.03c | 4.06±0.01a | 0.06±0.00c | 0.02±0.00b | 0.11±0.01b | 0.29±0.15cd | |
800 | 10.81 | 111.56 | 73.29 | 19.29±0.02b | 4.44±0.01b | 0.04±0.00e | 0.02±0.00c | 0.05±0.01c | 0.21±0.16cd | |
1,000 | 13.52 | 139.45 | 91.61 | 19.48±0.01a | 4.34±0.01c | 0.05±0.00d | 0.02±0.00b | 0.22±0.04a | 0.10±0.07d | |
Nurukzyme R400 | 200 | 19.00 | 3.75 | 21.10 | 16.60±0.02f | 3.81±0.03e | 0.07±0.00c | 0.02±0.00b | 2.61±1.47b | 3.80±0.17a |
400 | 38.00 | 7.49 | 42.20 | 16.94±0.02e | 3.66±0.02f | 0.09±0.00a | 0.02±0.00a | 0.53±0.08c | 2.23±0.24b | |
500 | 47.50 | 9.36 | 52.74 | 16.94±0.02c | 3.66±0.02d | 0.09±0.00b | 0.02±0.00b | 0.53±0.08c | 1.80±0.22bc | |
600 | 57.00 | 11.24 | 63.29 | 19.21±0.02b | 4.17±0.01a | 0.05±0.00e | 0.03±0.00a | 1.11±0.52c | 1.65±0.44bc | |
800 | 76.00 | 14.98 | 84.39 | 20.00±0.06a | 4.04±0.01b | 0.06±0.00d | 0.02±0.00c | 0.28±0.09c | 0.86±0.13c | |
1,000 | 95.00 | 18.73 | 105.49 | 18.14±0.02d | 3.97±0.03c | 0.07±0.00b | 0.02±0.00a | 4.40±0.67a | 0.48±0.23d | |
Sanferm yield | 200 | 2.88 | 45.04 | 28.10 | 9.13±0.03f | 3.69±0.03d | 0.10±0.00a | 0.02±0.01a | 0.08±0.01a | 2.75±0.18a |
400 | 5.75 | 90.07 | 56.19 | 14.41±0.01e | 4.04±0.04c | 0.05±0.00b | 0.02±0.01bc | 0.06±0.01b | 0.42±0.10b | |
500 | 7.19 | 112.59 | 70.24 | 15.76±0.06d | 4.29±0.03b | 0.03±0.00d | 0.01±0.00c | 0.08±0.01a | 0.33±0.10bc | |
600 | 8.63 | 135.11 | 84.29 | 19.01±0.03c | 4.34±0.06b | 0.04±0.00c | 0.02±0.00d | 0.05±0.01bc | 0.18±0.11bc | |
800 | 11.51 | 180.15 | 112.39 | 19.12±0.09b | 4.33±0.04b | 0.03±0.00d | 0.01±0.00bc | 0.04±0.01c | 0.18±0.10bc | |
1,000 | 14.38 | 225.18 | 140.48 | 19.38±0.02a | 4.50±0.05a | 0.03±0.00d | 0.01±0.00b | 0.04±0.01bc | 0.16±0.14c | |
Diazyme X4 | 200 | 24.16 | 0.14 | 24.24 | 11.80±0.02f | 3.74±0.01e | 0.10±0.00a | 0.02±0.00a | 0.06±0.01bc | 1.57±0.31a |
400 | 48.33 | 0.27 | 48.48 | 17.55±0.05e | 4.30±0.01d | 0.03±0.00bc | 0.02±0.00bc | 0.06±0.01c | 0.41±0.13b | |
500 | 60.41 | 0.34 | 60.60 | 18.63±0.01d | 4.43±0.01c | 0.03±0.00d | 0.02±0.00c | 0.04±0.00c | 0.30±0.21b | |
600 | 72.49 | 0.41 | 72.72 | 19.53±0.02b | 4.54±0.01b | 0.03±0.00d | 0.01±0.00c | 0.05±0.00c | 0.29±0.06b | |
800 | 96.66 | 0.54 | 96.96 | 19.53±0.02c | 4.54±0.01a | 0.03±0.00cd | 0.01±0.00bc | 0.05±0.00a | 0.29±0.06b | |
1,000 | 120.82 | 0.68 | 121.20 | 20.05±0.01a | 4.55±0.04b | 0.03±0.00b | 0.02±0.00b | 0.08±0.02b | 0.24±0.10b | |
CE | r | 0.514 | 0.151 | 0.720 | ||||||
p | 0.010 | 0.482 | 0.000 |